Meta-analysis of ultrasonography in diagnosis of deeply infiltrating endometriosis

( views:85, downloads:0 )
Author:
HUANG Xiu-feng(Department of Gynecology,Women's Hospital,School of Medicine,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310006,China)
HAN Chan-na(Department of Gynecology,Women's Hospital,School of Medicine,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310006,China)
LIN Kai-qing(Department of Gynecology,Women's Hospital,School of Medicine,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310006,China)
ZHANG Jing(Department of Gynecology,Women's Hospital,School of Medicine,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310006,China)
XU Hong(Department of Gynecology,Women's Hospital,School of Medicine,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310006,China)
ZHANG Xin-mei(Department of Gynecology,Women's Hospital,School of Medicine,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310006,China)
Journal Title:
CHINESE JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY
Issue:
Volume 45, Issue 04, 2010
DOI:
10.3760/cma.j.issn.0529-567x.2010.04.008
Key Word:
Endometriosis;Ultrasonography;Quality control;Meta-analysis

Abstract: Objective To evaluate the quality of literatures and the accuracy of ultrasonography in diagnosis of deeply infiltrating endometriosis(DIE).Methods The database of Medline (1966 to 2009), the excerpta medica database (EMBASE, 1980 to 2009), Chinese biological medicine on disc (CBMdisc, 1978 to 2009), China national knowledge infrastructure (CNKI, 1979 to 2009) and VIP for Chinese technology periodical database (VIP, 1989 to 2009) Cochrane library of studies about the diagnosis of ultrasound for DIE were searched and analyzed.Quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies (QUADAS) items were used to evaluate the quality of literatures.The sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio(+ LR), negative likelihood ratio (-LR) ,diagnostic test odds ratio (DOR) for the pooled analysis and heterogeneity test were analyzed for transvaginal ultrasonography(TVUS), transrectal ultrasonography (TRUS) and rectal endoscopic sonography(EUS) by Meta-disc software, and drew the summary receiver operating characteristic (SROC) curves for those without heterogeneity.Results Totally 15 literatures in English were enrolled into this study.The positive rate of 10 items of QUADAS were above 60%, whereas that of the 11th item "Were the reference standard results interpreted without knowledge of the results of the index test" was 46.7% ;none of studies had mentioned the 13th item " Were uninterpretable/intermediate test results reported".All researches had no heterogeneity by explored threshold effect.The results of pooled sensitivity, specificity, + LR, - LR, DOR were 0.925,0.986, 30.036,0.107, 299.25 for TRUS, 0.799,0.944,11.972,0.187, 69.126 for transvaginal ultrasonography (TVUS), and 0.635,0.928,8.022, O.320, 39.606 for EUS, respectively.Area under the curve of EUS was 0.9479, and that of TVUS was 0.9246.Conclusions TRUS,TVUS and EUS all showed optimal value in diagnosis of DIE.The bias identified from the 15 studies might be mainly resulted from reference standard review bias.

  • [1]Chapron C,Chopin N,Borghese B,et al.Deeply infiltrating endometriosis:pathogenetie implications of the anatomical distribution.Hum Reprod,2006,21:1839-1845.
  • [2]Penny W,Anne WSR,Johannes BR,et al.The development of QUADAS:a tool for the quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy included in systematic reviews.BMC Med Res Methodol,2003,3:25.
  • [3]Doniec JM,Kahlke V,Peetz F,et al.Rectal endometriosis:high sensitivity and specificity of endorectal ultrasound with an impact for the operative management.Dis Colon Rectum,2003,46:1667-1673.
  • [4]Bazot M,Detchev R,Cortez A,et al.Transvaginal sonography and rectal endoscopic sonography for the assessment of pelvic endometriosis:a preliminary comparison.Hum Reprod,2003,18:1686-1692.
  • [5]Dessote S,Farina M,Rubattu G,et al.Sonovaginography is a new technique for assessing rectovaginal endometriosis.Fertil Steril,2003,79:1023-1027.
  • [6]Delpy R,Barthet M,Gasmi M,et al.Value of endorectal ultrasonography for diagnosing rectovaginal septal endometriosis infiltrating the rectum.Endoscopy,2005,37:357-361.
  • [7]Chapron C,Vieira M,Chopin N,et al.Accuracy of rectal endoscopic uhrasonography and magnetic resonance imaging in the diagnosis of rectal involvement for patients presenting with deeply infiltrating endometriosis.Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol,2004,24:175-179.
  • [8]Abrao MS,Gonqalves MO,Gonzales M,et al.It is possible to evaluate deeply infiltrating endometriosis with transvaginal ultrasound.Eur J Obstet Gyneeol Reprod Biol,2005,123:14.
  • [9]Bahr A,de Parades V,Gadonneix P,et al.Endorectal ultrasonography in predicting rectal wall infiltration in patients with deep pelvic endometriosis:a modern tool for an ancient disease.Dis Colon Rectum,2006,49:869-875.
  • [10]Bazot M,Bornier C,Dubernard G,et al.Accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging and rectal endoscopic sonography for the prediction of location of deep pelvic endometriosis.Hum Reprod,2007,22:1457-1463.
  • [11]Guerriero S,Ajossa S,Gerada M,et al."Tenderness-guided" transvaginal uhrasonography:a new method for the detection of deep endometriosis in patients with chronic pelvic pain.Fertil Steril,2007,88:1293-1297.
  • [12]Abrao MS,Goncalves MO,Dias JA Jr,et al.Comparison between clinical examination,transvaginal sonography and magnetic resonance imaging for the diagnosis of deep endometriosis.Hum Reprod,2007,22:3092-3097.
  • [13]Valenzano MM,Remorgida V,Abbamonte LH,et al.Does transvaginal uhrasonography combined with water-contrast in the rectum aid in the diagnosis of rectovaginal endometriosis infiltrating the bowel? Hum Reprod,2008,23:1069-1075.
  • [14]Bazot M,Lafont C,Rouzier R,et al.Diagnostic accuracy of physical examination,transvaginal sonography,rectal endoscopic sonography,and magnetic resonance imaging to diagnose deep infiltrating endometriosis.Fertil Steril,2009,92:1825-1833.
  • [15]Guerriero S,Ajossa S,Gerada M,et al.Diagnostic value of transvaginal ' tenderness-guided ' ultrasonography for the prediction of location of deep endometriosis.Hum Reprod,2008,23:2452-2457.
  • [16]Griffiths A,Koutseuridou R,Vaughan S,et al.Transrectal ultrasound and the diagnosis of rectovaginal endometriosis:a prospective observational study.Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand,2008,87:445-448.
  • [17]Piketty M,Chopin N,Dousset B,et al.Preoperative work-up for patients with deeply infiltrating cndometriosis:transvaginal uhrasonography must definitely be the first-line imaging examination.Hum Reprod,2009,24:602-607.
  • [18]Bossuyt PM,Reitsma JB,Bruns DE,et al.The STARD statement for reporting studies of diagnostic accuracy:explanation and elaboration.Croat Med J,2003,44:639-650.
  • [19]郎景和.内异症研究的任务与展望(之二).中华妇产科杂志,2006,41:649-651.
WanfangData CO.,Ltd All Rights Reserved
About WanfangData | Contact US
Healthcare Department, Fuxing Road NO.15, Haidian District Beijing, 100038 P.R.China
Tel:+86-010-58882616 Fax:+86-010-58882615 Email:yiyao@wanfangdata.com.cn